Remove end-of-transmission message from protocol

Also update protobuf files definitions to latest version.

Change-Id: I0cd5d2d8deec5c787e2d3948d3d905fa672f9fea
Issue-ID: DCAEGEN2-775
Signed-off-by: Filip Krzywka <filip.krzywka@nokia.com>

6 files changed, 91 insertions, 162 deletions

diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/codec.kt b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/codec.kt
index c61ab266..4f867f13 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/codec.kt
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/codec.kt
@@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ import arrow.core.Left
 import arrow.core.Right
 import io.netty.buffer.ByteBuf
 import io.netty.buffer.ByteBufAllocator
-import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.PayloadWireFrameMessage.Companion.MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE
-import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.PayloadWireFrameMessage.Companion.RESERVED_BYTE_COUNT
+import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.WireFrameMessage.Companion.MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE
+import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.WireFrameMessage.Companion.RESERVED_BYTE_COUNT
 
 /**
  * @author Piotr Jaszczyk <piotr.jaszczyk@nokia.com>
@@ -33,19 +33,19 @@ import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.PayloadWireFrameMessage.Companion.R
  */
 class WireFrameEncoder(private val allocator: ByteBufAllocator = ByteBufAllocator.DEFAULT) {
 
-    fun encode(frame: PayloadWireFrameMessage): ByteBuf {
-        val bb = allocator.buffer(PayloadWireFrameMessage.HEADER_SIZE + frame.payload.size())
-
-        bb.writeByte(PayloadWireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE.toInt())
-        bb.writeByte(frame.versionMajor.toInt())
-        bb.writeByte(frame.versionMinor.toInt())
-        bb.writeZero(RESERVED_BYTE_COUNT)
-        bb.writeByte(frame.payloadTypeRaw.toInt())
-        bb.writeInt(frame.payloadSize)
-        frame.payload.writeTo(bb)
-
-        return bb
-    }
+    fun encode(frame: WireFrameMessage): ByteBuf = allocator
+            .buffer(WireFrameMessage.HEADER_SIZE + frame.payload.size())
+            .run {
+                writeByte(WireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE.toInt())
+                writeByte(frame.versionMajor.toInt())
+                writeByte(frame.versionMinor.toInt())
+                writeZero(RESERVED_BYTE_COUNT)
+                writeByte(frame.payloadType.toInt())
+                writeInt(frame.payloadSize)
+            }
+            .also {
+                frame.payload.writeTo(it)
+            }
 }
 
 /**
@@ -57,36 +57,20 @@ class WireFrameDecoder {
     fun decodeFirst(byteBuf: ByteBuf): Either<WireFrameDecodingError, WireFrameMessage> =
             when {
                 isEmpty(byteBuf) -> Left(EmptyWireFrame)
-                isSingleByte(byteBuf) -> lookForEOTFrame(byteBuf)
                 headerDoesNotFit(byteBuf) -> Left(MissingWireFrameHeaderBytes)
                 else -> parseWireFrame(byteBuf)
             }
 
     private fun isEmpty(byteBuf: ByteBuf) = byteBuf.readableBytes() < 1
 
-    private fun isSingleByte(byteBuf: ByteBuf) = byteBuf.readableBytes() == 1
-
-    private fun headerDoesNotFit(byteBuf: ByteBuf) = byteBuf.readableBytes() < PayloadWireFrameMessage.HEADER_SIZE
-
-    private fun lookForEOTFrame(byteBuf: ByteBuf): Either<WireFrameDecodingError, EndOfTransmissionMessage> {
-        byteBuf.markReaderIndex()
-        val byte = byteBuf.readUnsignedByte()
-
-        return if (byte == EndOfTransmissionMessage.MARKER_BYTE) {
-            Right(EndOfTransmissionMessage)
-        } else {
-            byteBuf.resetReaderIndex()
-            Left(MissingWireFrameHeaderBytes)
-        }
-    }
+    private fun headerDoesNotFit(byteBuf: ByteBuf) = byteBuf.readableBytes() < WireFrameMessage.HEADER_SIZE
 
     private fun parseWireFrame(byteBuf: ByteBuf): Either<WireFrameDecodingError, WireFrameMessage> {
         byteBuf.markReaderIndex()
 
         val mark = byteBuf.readUnsignedByte()
         return when (mark) {
-            EndOfTransmissionMessage.MARKER_BYTE -> Right(EndOfTransmissionMessage)
-            PayloadWireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE -> parsePayloadFrame(byteBuf)
+            WireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE -> parsePayloadFrame(byteBuf)
             else -> {
                 byteBuf.resetReaderIndex()
                 Left(InvalidWireFrameMarker(mark))
@@ -94,7 +78,7 @@ class WireFrameDecoder {
         }
     }
 
-    private fun parsePayloadFrame(byteBuf: ByteBuf): Either<WireFrameDecodingError, PayloadWireFrameMessage> {
+    private fun parsePayloadFrame(byteBuf: ByteBuf): Either<WireFrameDecodingError, WireFrameMessage> {
         val versionMajor = byteBuf.readUnsignedByte()
         val versionMinor = byteBuf.readUnsignedByte()
         byteBuf.skipBytes(RESERVED_BYTE_COUNT) // reserved
@@ -113,7 +97,7 @@ class WireFrameDecoder {
 
         val payload = ByteData.readFrom(byteBuf, payloadSize)
 
-        return Right(PayloadWireFrameMessage(payload, versionMajor, versionMinor, payloadTypeRaw, payloadSize))
+        return Right(WireFrameMessage(payload, versionMajor, versionMinor, payloadTypeRaw, payloadSize))
 
     }
 }
diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/errors.kt b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/errors.kt
index d82bb25f..dfadc5b8 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/errors.kt
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/errors.kt
@@ -19,7 +19,7 @@
  */
 package org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain
 
-import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.PayloadWireFrameMessage.Companion.MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE
+import org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain.WireFrameMessage.Companion.MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE
 
 /**
  * @author Piotr Jaszczyk <piotr.jaszczyk@nokia.com>
@@ -35,7 +35,7 @@ sealed class InvalidWireFrame(msg: String) : WireFrameDecodingError(msg)
 
 class InvalidWireFrameMarker(actualMarker: Short) : InvalidWireFrame(
         "Invalid start of frame. Expected 0x%02X, but was 0x%02X"
-                .format(PayloadWireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE, actualMarker)
+                .format(WireFrameMessage.MARKER_BYTE, actualMarker)
 )
 
 object PayloadSizeExceeded : InvalidWireFrame("payload size exceeds the limit ($MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE bytes)")
@@ -47,9 +47,3 @@ sealed class MissingWireFrameBytes(msg: String) : WireFrameDecodingError(msg)
 object MissingWireFrameHeaderBytes : MissingWireFrameBytes("readable bytes < header size")
 object MissingWireFramePayloadBytes : MissingWireFrameBytes("readable bytes < payload size")
 object EmptyWireFrame : MissingWireFrameBytes("empty wire frame")
-
-
-// Other
-
-class UnknownWireFrameTypeException(frame: WireFrameMessage)
-    : Throwable("Unexpected wire frame message type: ${frame.javaClass}")
diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/wire_frame.kt b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/wire_frame.kt
index 642179e1..06ca9383 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/wire_frame.kt
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/kotlin/org/onap/dcae/collectors/veshv/domain/wire_frame.kt
@@ -20,10 +20,8 @@
 package org.onap.dcae.collectors.veshv.domain
 
 
-sealed class WireFrameMessage
-
 /**
- * Wire frame structure is presented bellow. All fields are in network byte order (big-endian).
+ * Wire frame structure is presented bellow using ASN.1 notation. All fields are in network byte order (big-endian).
  *
  * ```
  * -- Precedes every HV-VES message
@@ -31,21 +29,22 @@ sealed class WireFrameMessage
  *   magic           INTEGER (0..255),         – always 0xFF, identifies extended header usage
  *   versionMajor    INTEGER (0..255),         – major interface v, forward incompatible with previous major v
  *   versionMinor    INTEGER (0..255),         – minor interface v, forward compatible with previous minor v
- *   reserved        BIT STRING (SIZE (16)),   – reserved for future use
- *   messageType     INTEGER (0..255),         – message payload type: 0x00=undefined, 0x01=protobuf
- *   messageLength   INTEGER (0..4294967295)   – message payload length
+ *   reserved        OCTET STRING (SIZE (3)),  – reserved for future use
+ *   payloadId       INTEGER (0..255),         – message payload type: 0x00=undefined, 0x01=protobuf
+ *   payloadLength   INTEGER (0..4294967295)   – message payload length
+ *   payload         OCTET STRING              – length as per payloadLength
  * }
  * ```
  *
  * @author Piotr Jaszczyk <piotr.jaszczyk@nokia.com>
  * @since May 2018
  */
-data class PayloadWireFrameMessage(val payload: ByteData,
-                                   val versionMajor: Short,
-                                   val versionMinor: Short,
-                                   val payloadTypeRaw: Short,
-                                   val payloadSize: Int
-) : WireFrameMessage() {
+data class WireFrameMessage(val payload: ByteData,
+                            val versionMajor: Short,
+                            val versionMinor: Short,
+                            val payloadType: Short,
+                            val payloadSize: Int
+) {
     constructor(payload: ByteArray) : this(
             ByteData(payload),
             SUPPORTED_VERSION_MAJOR,
@@ -55,7 +54,7 @@ data class PayloadWireFrameMessage(val payload: ByteData,
 
     fun isValid(): Boolean =
             versionMajor == SUPPORTED_VERSION_MAJOR
-                    && PayloadContentType.isValidHexValue(payloadTypeRaw)
+                    && PayloadContentType.isValidHexValue(payloadType)
                     && payload.size() == payloadSize
 
     companion object {
@@ -74,24 +73,3 @@ data class PayloadWireFrameMessage(val payload: ByteData,
         const val MAX_PAYLOAD_SIZE = 1024 * 1024
     }
 }
-
-
-/**
- * This message type should be used by client to indicate that he has finished sending data to collector.
- *
- * Wire frame structure is presented bellow. All fields are in network byte order (big-endian).
- *
- * ```
- * -- Sent by the HV-VES data provider, prior to closing the connection to the HV-VES destination
- * Eot ::= SEQUENCE {
- *   magic           INTEGER (0..255),           – always 0xAA
- * }
- * ```
- *
- * @since July 2018
- */
-
-object EndOfTransmissionMessage : WireFrameMessage() {
-    const val MARKER_BYTE: Short = 0xAA
-}
-
diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/event/VesEvent.proto b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/event/VesEvent.proto
index 54a6d149..0f9e5e1f 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/event/VesEvent.proto
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/event/VesEvent.proto
@@ -21,54 +21,55 @@ syntax = "proto3";
 package org.onap.ves;
 
 message VesEvent {
-    CommonEventHeader commonEventHeader = 1; // required
+    CommonEventHeader commonEventHeader=1;  // required
 
-    oneof eventFields // required, payload
-    {
-        // each new high-volume domain can add an entry for its own GPB message
-        // the field can be opaque (bytes) to allow decoding the payload in a separate step
-        bytes hvMeasFields = 2; // for domain==HVMEAS, GPB message: HVMeasFields
-    }
+    bytes eventFields=2;                    // required, payload
+    // this field contains a domain-specific GPB message
+    // the field being opaque (bytes), the decoding of the payload occurs in a separate step
+    // the name of the GPB message for domain XYZ is XYZFields
+    // e.g. for domain==HVMEAS, the GPB message is HVMEASFields
 }
 
 // VES CommonEventHeader adapted to GPB (Google Protocol Buffers)
-// Aligned with VES 7.0.1 schema, and extending to hvMeas Domain
+// Aligned with VES 7.0.1 schema, and extending to hvMeas Domain.
 
-message CommonEventHeader {
-    string version = 1;               // required, "version of the gpb common event header"
-    string domain = 2;                // required, "the eventing domain associated with the event", allowed values:
-                                      // FAULT, HEARTBEAT, MEASUREMENT, MOBILE_FLOW, OTHER, PNFREGISTRATION, SIP_SIGNALING,
-                                      // STATE_CHANGE, SYSLOG, THRESHOLD_CROSSING_ALERT, VOICE_QUALITY, HVMEAS
+message CommonEventHeader
+{
+    string version = 1;                     // required, "version of the gpb common event header"
+    string domain = 2;                      // required, "the eventing domain associated with the event", allowed values:
+    // FAULT, HEARTBEAT, MEASUREMENT, MOBILE_FLOW, OTHER, PNFREGISTRATION, SIP_SIGNALING,
+    // STATE_CHANGE, SYSLOG, THRESHOLD_CROSSING_ALERT, VOICE_QUALITY, HVMEAS
 
-    uint32 sequence = 3;              // required, "ordering of events communicated by an event source instance or 0 if not needed"
+    uint32 sequence = 3;                    // required, "ordering of events communicated by an event source instance or 0 if not needed"
 
-    enum Priority {
+    enum Priority
+    {
         PRIORITY_NOT_PROVIDED = 0;
         HIGH = 1;
         MEDIUM = 2;
         NORMAL = 3;
         LOW = 4;
     }
-    Priority priority = 4;            // required, "processing priority"
+    Priority priority = 4;                  // required, "processing priority"
 
-    string eventId = 5;               // required, "event key that is unique to the event source"
-    string eventName = 6;             // required, "unique event name"
-    string eventType = 7;             // "for example - guest05,  platform"
+    string eventId = 5;                     // required, "event key that is unique to the event source"
+    string eventName = 6;                   // required, "unique event name"
+    string eventType = 7;                   // "for example - guest05,  platform"
 
-    uint64 lastEpochMicrosec = 8;     // required, "the latest unix time aka epoch time associated with the event from any component--as microseconds elapsed since 1 Jan 1970 not including leap seconds"
-    uint64 startEpochMicrosec = 9;    // required, "the earliest unix time aka epoch time associated with the event from any component--as microseconds elapsed since 1 Jan 1970 not including leap seconds"
+    uint64 lastEpochMicrosec = 8;           // required, "the latest unix time aka epoch time associated with the event from any component--as microseconds elapsed since 1 Jan 1970 not including leap seconds"
+    uint64 startEpochMicrosec = 9;          // required, "the earliest unix time aka epoch time associated with the event from any component--as microseconds elapsed since 1 Jan 1970 not including leap seconds"
 
-    string nfNamingCode = 10;         // "4 character network function type, aligned with vnf naming standards"
-    string nfcNamingCode = 11;        // "3 character network function component type, aligned with vfc naming standards"
-    string nfVendorName = 12;         // " Vendor Name providing the nf "
+    string nfNamingCode = 10;               // "4 character network function type, aligned with vnf naming standards"
+    string nfcNamingCode = 11;              // "3 character network function component type, aligned with vfc naming standards"
+    string nfVendorName = 12;               // " Vendor Name providing the nf "
 
-    bytes reportingEntityId = 13;     // "UUID identifying the entity reporting the event, for example an OAM VM; must be populated by the ATT enrichment process"
-    string reportingEntityName = 14;  // required, "name of the entity reporting the event, for example, an EMS name; may be the same as sourceName should match A&AI entry"
-    bytes sourceId = 15;              // "UUID identifying the entity experiencing the event issue; must be populated by the ATT enrichment process"
-    string sourceName = 16;           // required, "name of the entity experiencing the event issued use A&AI entry"
-    string timeZoneOffset = 17;       // "Offset to GMT to indicate local time zone for the device"
-    string vesEventListenerVersion = 18; // required, "Version of the VesEvent Listener"
+    bytes reportingEntityId = 13;           // "UUID identifying the entity reporting the event, for example an OAM VM; must be populated by the ATT enrichment process"
+    string reportingEntityName = 14;        // required, "name of the entity reporting the event, for example, an EMS name; may be the same as sourceName should match A&AI entry"
+    bytes sourceId = 15;                    // "UUID identifying the entity experiencing the event issue; must be populated by the ATT enrichment process"
+    string sourceName = 16;                 // required, "name of the entity experiencing the event issued use A&AI entry"
+    string timeZoneOffset = 17;             // "Offset to GMT to indicate local time zone for the device"
+    string vesEventListenerVersion = 18;    // required, "Version of the VesEvent Listener"
 
-    reserved "InternalHeaderFields";  // "enrichment fields for internal VES Event Listener service use only, not supplied by event sources"
+    reserved "InternalHeaderFields";        // "enrichment fields for internal VES Event Listener service use only, not supplied by event sources"
     reserved 100;
 }
diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/HVMeasFields.proto b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/HVMeasFields.proto
index 9a8582d5..94b40106 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/HVMeasFields.proto
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/HVMeasFields.proto
@@ -24,20 +24,14 @@ import "MeasDataCollection.proto";          // for 3GPP PM format
 message HVMeasFields

 {

     string hvMeasFieldsVersion = 1;

-    measDataCollection.MeasDataCollection measDataCollection = 2;

-    // From 3GPP TS 28.550

+    MeasDataCollection measDataCollection = 2;

+    // Based on 3GPP TS 28.550

     // Informative: mapping between similar header fields (format may be different)

-    // 3GPP MeasStreamHeader   ONAP/VES CommonEventHeader

+    // 3GPP MeasHeader         ONAP/VES CommonEventHeader

     // senderName              sourceName

     // senderType              nfNamingCode + nfcNamingCode

     // vendorName              nfVendorName

     // collectionBeginTime     startEpochMicrosec

     // timestamp               lastEpochMicrosec

-    repeated HashMap eventAddlFlds = 3;     // optional per-event data

+    map<string, string> eventAddlFlds = 3;     // optional per-event data (name/value HashMap)

 }

-

-message HashMap

-{

-    string name = 1;

-    string value = 2;

-}
\ No newline at end of file
diff --git a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/MeasDataCollection.proto b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/MeasDataCollection.proto
index 472dcc43..31f4dfb1 100644
--- a/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/MeasDataCollection.proto
+++ b/hv-collector-domain/src/main/proto/measurements/MeasDataCollection.proto
@@ -18,87 +18,65 @@
  * ============LICENSE_END=========================================================

  */

 syntax = "proto3";

-package measDataCollection;

+package org.onap.ves;

 

-// Definition for RTPM, structure aligned with 3GPP PM format optimized for RTPM delivery pre-standard TS 28.550 V1.2.2 (2018-08).

+// Definition for RTPM, structure aligned with 3GPP PM format optimized for RTPM delivery pre-standard TS 28.550 V2.0.0 (2018-09).

 // Some field details are taken from 3GPP TS 32.436 V15.0.0 (2018-06) ASN.1 file.

-// Note (2018-08): work is in progress for 3GPP TS 28.550 to specify PM streaming format. Changes will be made, if needed, to align with final version.

+// Note (2018-09): work is in progress for 3GPP TS 28.550. Changes will be made, if needed, to align with final version.

 // Differences/additions to 3GPP TS 28.550 are marked with "%%".

 

-message MeasDataCollection                  // top-level message 

+message MeasDataCollection                  // top-level message

 {

-    MeasHeader measHeader = 1;

-    repeated MeasData measData = 2;         // %%: use a single instance for RTPM

-    MeasFooter measFooter = 3;

-}

-

-message MeasHeader

-{

-    string streamFormatVersion = 1;

+    // %% Combined messageFileHeader, measData (single instance), messageFileFooter (not needed: timestamp = collectionBeginTime + granularityPeriod).

+    string formatVersion = 1;

     string senderName = 2;

     string senderType = 3;

     string vendorName = 4;

     string collectionBeginTime = 5;         // in ASN.1 GeneralizedTime format (subset of ISO 8601 basic format)

+    uint32 granularityPeriod = 6;           // duration in seconds, %% moved from MeasInfo (single reporting period per event)

+    string measuredEntityUserName = 7;      // network function user definable name ("userLabel") defined for the measured entity in 3GPP TS 28.622

+    string measuredEntityDn = 8;            // DN as per 3GPP TS 32.300

+    string measuredEntitySoftwareVersion = 9;

+    repeated string measObjInstIdList = 10; // %%: optional, monitored object LDNs as per 3GPP TS 32.300 and 3GPP TS 32.432

+    repeated MeasInfo measInfo = 11;

 }

 

-message MeasData

-{

-    string measuredEntityId = 1;            // DN as per 3GPP TS 32.300

-    string measuredEntityUserName = 2;      // network function User Name

-    string measuredEntitySoftwareVersion = 3;

-    uint32 granularityPeriod = 4;           // in seconds, %% moved from MeasInfo (single reporting period per event)

-    repeated string measObjInstIdList = 5;  // %%: optional, monitored object LDNs as per 3GPP TS 32.300 and 3GPP TS 32.432

-    repeated MeasInfo measInfo = 6; 

-}

-

-

 message MeasInfo

 {

     oneof MeasInfoId {                      // measurement group identifier

-        uint32 iMeasInfoId = 1;             // identifier as integer (%%: more compact)

-        string measInfoId = 2;              // identifier as string (more generic)

+                                            uint32 iMeasInfoId = 1;             // identifier as integer (%%: more compact)

+                                            string measInfoId = 2;              // identifier as string (more generic)

     }

 

     oneof MeasTypes {                       // measurement identifiers associated with the measurement results

-        IMeasTypes iMeasTypes = 3;          // identifiers as integers (%%: more compact)

-        SMeasTypes measTypes = 4;           // identifiers as strings (more generic)

+                                            IMeasTypes iMeasTypes = 3;          // identifiers as integers (%%: more compact)

+                                            SMeasTypes measTypes = 4;           // identifiers as strings (more generic)

     }

     // Needed only because GPB does not support repeated fields directly inside 'oneof'

     message IMeasTypes { repeated uint32 iMeasType = 1; }

     message SMeasTypes { repeated string measType = 1; }

 

-    string jobIdList = 5;

-    repeated MeasValue measValues = 6;      // performance measurements grouped by measurement groups

+    string jobId = 5;

+    repeated MeasValue measValues = 6;      // performance measurements grouped by measurement object

 }

 

 message MeasValue

 {

     oneof MeasObjInstId {                   // monitored object LDN as per 3GPP TS 32.300 and 3GPP TS 32.432

-        string measObjInstId = 1;           // LDN itself

-        uint32 measObjInstIdListIdx = 2;    // %%: index into measObjInstIdList

+                                            string measObjInstId = 1;           // LDN itself

+                                            uint32 measObjInstIdListIdx = 2;    // %%: index into measObjInstIdList

     }

     repeated MeasResult measResults = 3;

     bool suspectFlag = 4;

-    repeated nameValue measObjAddlFlds = 5; // %%: optional per-object data

+    map<string, string> measObjAddlFlds = 5; // %%: optional per-object data (name/value HashMap)

 }

 

 message MeasResult

 {

-    uint32 p = 1;                           // Optional index in the MeasTypes array

+    uint32 p = 1;                           // Index in the MeasTypes array, needed only if measResults has fewer elements than MeasTypes

     oneof xValue {

         sint64 iValue = 2;

         double rValue = 3;

         bool isNull = 4;

     }

 }

-

-message MeasFooter

-{

-    string timestamp = 1;                   // in ASN.1 GeneralizedTime format, a better name would be "collectionEndTime"

-}

-

-message nameValue                           // %%: vendor-defined name-value pair

-{

-    string name = 1;

-    string value = 2;

-} 
\ No newline at end of file